G1121

Winter Deicing Agents for the Homeowner

Information on deicers and how they affect plants is covered here.


Jay B. Fitzgerald, Extension Horticulturist
Donald E. Janssen, Associate Extension Agriculturist


Slick sidewalks and roads are hazardous. Removing compacted snow and ice with shovels or snow blowers is not always an easy task. Deicers can help by “undercutting,” or loosening the snow or ice because they lower the freezing point of water.

However, deicers can affect plants so use them with care.

Do not use deicers to completely melt snow or ice, but to make their removal easier. Deicers melt down through the ice or snow to the hard surface, then spread out underneath. This undercuts and loosens the snow so shoveling and plowing can be done.

Research has shown that the shape of deicing particles affects the speed of their penetration through ice. Uniformly shaped spherical pellets of about 1/16” to 3/16” penetrate ice faster and more efficiently than other shapes. Irregularly shaped particles tend to melt randomly in all directions. Flakes melt as much horizontally as they do vertically.

Five chemicals commonly are used as deicers. They can be used alone, they often are blended together or combined with other materials to enhance their performance.

Calcium Chloride

This product is available in flakes, pellets or liquid. Calcium chloride produces an exothermic reaction, giving off heat. Because of this, it often performs better than many other deicing salts, especially at lower temperatures. Some highway departments spray liquid calcium chloride over rock salt to lower its melting temperature.

Sodium Chloride

Rock salt first was used as a road deicer in the 1940s. An estimated 10 to 14 million tons will be used yearly on roads in the United States and Canada. Sodium chloride is relatively inexpensive, but it can burn plants and corrode metal and concrete. Sodium chloride is the salt most commonly used to season food.

Potassium Chloride

A naturally-occurring material that also is used as a fertilizer (muriate of potash) and food salt substitute, potassium chloride’s high salt index has the potential to burn foliage and inhibit rooting.

Urea

Synthesized from ammonia and carbon dioxide, urea is used primarily as a fertilizer. It has a lower burn potential than potassium chloride, and is a source of nitrogen fertilizer. Adjacent turf may green and grow excessively in the spring. If urea remains on top of the soil, it rapidly breaks down to ammonia, which escapes into the air.

Calcium magnesium acetate (CMA)

This is a salt-free melting agent. It is made from dolomitic limestone and acetic acid (the principal compound of vinegar). CMA is being researched as an alternative to salts for environmentally sensitive areas. The product is being used on bridges sensitive to salt corrosion. Studies have shown the material has little impact on plants and animals.

Concrete paving, such as driveways, walks and steps may be damaged by deicing chemicals. The most common winter damage is scaling, which is caused by cycles of freezing and thawing caused by the deicing agent. Water can be absorbed into the very fine capillary space in the concrete. When it freezes and expands, small flakes of mortar and concrete come loose from the surface.

Concrete also can be damaged by the formation of salt crystals that have a similar effect as water freezing. To prevent freeze-thaw damage (scaling), make sure all concrete-paved surfaces are composed of air-entrained concrete and have proper cement content. Air-entrained concrete has minute air bubbles to increase resilience and resistance to wear. Strength also is important for a durable, scale resistant concrete. The concrete should be correctly cured; new concrete should be air dried for at least 30 days prior to the first freeze. Sealers may be applied to prevent the concrete from absorbing water and salts. Additional information pertaining to more specific questions on concrete may be addressed to: Portland Cement Association, Dept. Ne, 5420 Old Orchard Road, Skokie, IL, 60077.

Some deicing chemicals are more damaging to concrete surfaces than others. Products such as ammonium nitrate or ammonium sulfate tend to damage concrete more than sodium chloride or calcium chloride.

Improper use of deicing agents may cause injury to plants. Excess salts and fertilization from deicers impede uptake of nutrients. Plants cannot absorb sufficient water even when moisture is plentiful.

Symptoms of salt injury include desiccation, stunting and dieback. Leaf tips and margins appear burned. Roots may be injured.

Plants may be protected from injury by direct exposure to salt spray by covering them with burlap or saran cloth to decrease the amount of exposure to slush during snow removal. Accumulation of salt in the soil over several years may cause progressive decline and eventual death of plants. Where deicing agents are used, flushing the soil with large amounts of water after the last freeze may alleviate burn potential. Always read and follow label directions when using any product, including deicers.

Aerial salt spray tolerance of landscape plants
*For soil salt tolerance ratings, see designation after plant name. (S)–Sensitive, (I)–Intermediate, (T)–Tolerant
Sensitive Intermediate Tolerant
Deciduous Trees
Carpinus caroliniana (S)
American Hornbean
Acer ginnala
Amur Maple
Acer platanoides (I)
Norway Maple
Celtis occidentalis
Hackberry
A. negundo (I)
Boxelder
A. saccharinum (I)
Silver Maple
Cercis canadenis (I)
Eastern Redbud
A. rubrum (S)
Red Maple
Aesculus hippocastanum (T)
European Horsechestnut
Crataequs spp.
Hawthorn
A. saccharum (S)
Sugar Maple
Allanthus altissima (T)
Tree-of-Heaven
Fagus grandifolia (S)
American Beech
Alnus spp. (S)
Alder
Elaeagnus angustifolia (T)
Russian olive
Liriodendron tulipfera (S)
Tuliptree
Amelanchier spp.
Serviceberry
Fraxinus americana (T)
White Ash
Malus spp. (I)
Crabapple
Betula spp. (I)
Birch
Gleditsia triacanthos (T)
Honeylocust
Prunus serotina (T)
Black Cherry
Catalpa speciosa
Catalpa
Juglans nigra (S)
Black Walnut

Quercus alba (T)
White Oak

Fraxinus pennsylvanica
Green Ash
Populus spp. (I)
Poplar
Q. palustris
Pin Oak
Pyrus spp.
Pear

Robinia pseudoacacia (T)
Black Locust

Q. rubra (T)
Red Oak
Quercus macrocarpa (T)
Bur Oak
Sorbus decora
Mountain ash
Tilia cordata (S)
Littleleaf Linden
Salix alba tristis
Golden Weeping Willow
 
Tilia americana (S)
American Linden
   
Ulmus americana
American Elm
   
Shrubs
Berberis thunbergii (S)
Japanese Barberry
Alnus rugosa (S)
Speckled Alder
Caragana arborescens
Siberian Peashrub
Buxus sempervirens (S)
Common Box
Berberis koreana
Korean Barberry
Euronymus alata (S)
Winged Euonymus
Chaenomeles speciosa
Flowering quince
Forsythia x intermedia
Border Forsythia
Juniperus chinensis ‘Pfitzerana’ (T)
Pfitzer Juniper
Cornus spp.
Dogwood
Juniperus horizontalis
Creeping Juniper
 
Corylus spp. (S)
Hazelnut
J.h. ‘Plumosa’ (I)
Andora Creeping Juniper
Philadelphia
Mock orange
Euonymus europea (S)
European Euonymus
Liqustrum spp. (I)
Privet
Rhamnus spp.
Buckthorn
Sambucus canadensis
American Elder
Lonicera spp. (I)
Honeysuckle
Rhus aromatica
Fragrant Sumac
Spiraea spp.
Spirea
Syringa vulgaris
Common Lilac
R. typhina
Staghorn Sumac
Symphoricarpos orbiculatus
Indiancurrant
Coralberry
Viburnum dentatum (S)
Arrowood Viburnum
Kibes alpinum
Alpine Currant
Viburnum lantana (S)
Wayfaringtree Viburnum
V. lentago (S)
Nannyberry Viburnum
Rosa rugosa
Rugosa rose
V. trilobum (S)
American Cranberrybush
Viburnum
Symphoricarpos albus
Snowberry
 
  Syringa reticulata
Japanese Tree Lilac
 
  Tamariz ramosissima
Five-stamen Tamariz
 
Coniferous Trees
Abies balsamea (I)
Balsam Fir
Juniperus spp.
Juniper
Juniper virginiana
Eastern Redcedar
Metasequola glyptostroboides
Dawn Redwood
Picea abies (S)
Norway Spruce
Larix decidua (S)
European Larch
Picea glauca (I)
White Spruce
Pinus ponderosa (I)
Ponderosa Pine
Picea pungens (S)
Colorado Spruce
Pinus resinosa
Red Pine
Pseudotsuga menziesil (S)
Douglas Fir
Pinus banksiana
Jack Pine
P. strobus (S)
Eastern White Pine
  P. nigra
Austrian Pine
P. sylvestris
Scotch Pine
   
Taxus spp.
Yew
   
Thuja occidentalis (I)
American Arborvitae
   
Tsuga canadensis (S)
Canada Hemlock
   

 



Visit the University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension Publications Web site for more publications.
Index Lawn & Garden
Miscellaneous
1992, Revised February 2007

Extension is a Division of the Institute of Agriculture and Natural Resources at the University of Nebraska–Lincoln cooperating with the Counties and the United States Department of Agriculture.

University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension educational programs abide with the nondiscrimination policies of the University of Nebraska–Lincoln and the United States Department of Agriculture.

© 1992, 1995-2007, The Board of Regents of the University of Nebraska on behalf of the University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension. All rights reserved.